Scott's Bar-B-Que/Lewis Bar-B-Que

[InletCock1989]

Originally Posted by cack

Uummm, his dad retired a good while ago ...

Ummmmmm, Wrong. Take it from someone who’s born and raised in Hemingway.

[CockRoche]

I've recently bought a kamado cooker and a brisket is on my list to try. I'd like to try out that place so I would know if I'm doing it right. I've seen a lot of people say their's turns out tasting like regular old roast beef.

[BigRedCock]

Originally Posted by InletCock1989

Ummmmmm, Wrong. Take it from someone who’s born and raised in Hemingway.

And he knows people in Indiana Inlet is foolish

[InletCock1989]

Originally Posted by BigRedCock

And he knows people in Indiana Inlet is foolish

Okie dokie

[Copperhead]

I honestly have no real legitimate reason to ever set foot in Lewis' ever again. I've been twice(2nd time I had no choice)
The turkey was dry and frankly believe the pork is better at fn Melvins in Mt P.
My friend's brisket is just as good if not better.
Left both times feeling completely ripped off. Never again.
$8-$10 for a drink.
Lmao at anyone who leaves this place feeling fullfilled instead of a flat out sucker

[Three and Out]

Originally Posted by Copperhead

I honestly have no real legitimate reason to ever set foot in Lewis' ever again. I've been twice(2nd time I had no choice)
The turkey was dry and frankly believe the pork is better at fn Melvins in Mt P.
My friend's brisket is just as good if not better.
Left both times feeling completely ripped off. Never again.
$8-$10 for a drink.
Lmao at anyone who leaves this place feeling fullfilled instead of a flat out sucker

I’ve never been to either but why would a BBQ place serve turkey. That’s almost a disqualifier right there.

[dreammachine]

Since there are some great Bar-B-Que Restaurants in the Greater Charleston Area and since we have these two new ones there, could someone do a list of the best ten in their best Bar-B-Que opinion?

I have tried Melvin's and really like it. The place on the Savannah Hwy was pretty good too, just can't remember the name of it. Just don't know a lot about other BBQ places down there as I usually focus on the great seafood in the Charleston Area.

[RoosterBooster]

Originally Posted by SterlingBrooks

I like Scott's and Lewis is ok. Wise bbq in Clinton and pigout in Inman have them both beat imo.. especially in the sauce category.

Wises is not bad, but you can't even compare a place that doesn't cook on wood to Scott's (I haven't tried the Charleston version, so referring to Hemmingway) or Lewis's. Drive to the other side of Newberry, Cannon's does a lot better job than Wise's.

[RoosterBooster]

Originally Posted by Three and Out

I’ve never been to either but why would a BBQ place serve turkey. That’s almost a disqualifier right there.

Texas BBQ it's pretty common.

[usc_thereal]

I can't even compare Scott's to Lewis'. Scott's is where you want to get your "barbecue," i.e., pulled pork with vinegar pepper sauce. Lewis' is where you want to get your "Texas" brisky, i.e., kosher salt, coarse black pepper, and maybe some garlic.

Scott's is the best pulled pork I've ever had. Granted, I'm referring to Scott's in Hemingway, but I know it's the same sauce. I grew up in LC down the road from Scott's and it's the best pulled pork bar none.

[rabid cock]

Originally Posted by dreammachine

The place on the Savannah Hwy was pretty good too, just can't remember the name of it.

Bessinger's.

[Garnet&BLK]

Swig & Swine is better than both to me. It’s also much better priced. Lewis’s is better than Rodney Scott’s though.

[pitchcock]

I haven't been to Scott's in Charleston yet, but I went to Lewis's twice after they opened.

My take on Lewis's....overpriced downtown food designed for trendy wannabe's and hipsters. It was generally underwhelming.

The sausage was good, brisket was ok, but as someone else noted Swig and Swine has overall better Q and better sides. In fact, I'd rather get the generic weekend buffet at Bessingers on Savannah Highway than go back to Lewis's....more variety and all you can eat, and you'll wind up spending less money.

Some of the reviews I've read on Scott's has me concerned he's going to fall into that downtown trap of high prices/small portions, but I have to get over there and see what he has.

[dreammachine]

It is a good one and I have been there a few times and also to the one over at Mt. Pleasant.

[dreammachine]

Originally Posted by pitchcock

I haven't been to Scott's in Charleston yet, but I went to Lewis's twice after they opened.

My take on Lewis's....overpriced downtown food designed for trendy wannabe's and hipsters. It was generally underwhelming.

The sausage was good, brisket was ok, but as someone else noted Swig and Swine has overall better Q and better sides. In fact, I'd rather get the generic weekend buffet at Bessingers on Savannah Highway than go back to Lewis's....more variety and all you can eat, and you'll wind up spending less money.

Some of the reviews I've read on Scott's has me concerned he's going to fall into that downtown trap of high prices/small portions, but I have to get over there and see what he has.

That would be sad as he seems like the "Real Deal"???

[ipull4usc]

Lewis BBQ is very good but overpriced. I generally get a sandwich there because it seems to be the best value. Their sides are limited but pretty good. Overall it's very good though and I end up going about once every 2 weeks.

I've given the Scott's on King St a chance about 5-6 times and each time it's been extremely disappointing. BBQ is dry and tasteless.

[dreammachine]

Well, I finally got a chance to go to Rodney Scott's Bar-B-Que Restaurant in Charleston, SC today and I am going to tell you - IT WAS OUTSTANDING!!! We had the pull pork, which was awesome, ribs that were so good that I almost ordered me another plate of them. The sides we had were Mac & Cheese and Collard Greens and I have got to say that both were Top Of The Line For Me. I have eaten Bar-B-Que all across SC and GA and this was as good or better than any I have ever had.

Rodney Scott came out to my booth and spoke with me and my wife and is a very nice fellow - who knows his craft very well. I would find it hard to say I did not like this bar-b-que unless Rodney Scott had a bad day. This was a great meal, he is a good guy, and every time I go back to Charleston, SC, I will make a special trip to go by and visit this great Bar-B-Que Restaurant.

[dreammachine]

Anybody been to Rodney Scott's Bar-B-Que Restaurant lately? I enjoyed my time there and would go back if I am in Charleston.

[InletCock1989]

Honestly, people down here don’t even get BBQ from Rosey Scott’s; hell we prefer Big D’s down here. Rodney isn’t really greeted and liked down here, which is why he went to Charleston.

[dreammachine]

Originally Posted by InletCock1989

Honestly, people down here don’t even get BBQ from Rosey Scott’s; hell we prefer Big D’s down here. Rodney isn’t really greeted and liked down here, which is why he went to Charleston.

I have never been to the one in Hemingway yet, but Rodney Scott's place in Charleston, SC is doing well and he has gotten a lot of free advertisement on a couple of food shows. I have been to Rodney Scott's Bar-B-Que in Charleston, SC and they were coming by in bus loads and the place was packed. I have eaten as good or better Bar-B-Q at other places in our great state, but Rodney Scott's is very good and would be in my Top 5 in our state.